======================================== aVTC Test "2004-07" (File 6mCMP32.TXT): ---------------------------------------- Comparison of Detection Quality of 32-Bit Scanning Engines: (Win-2000 / Win-XP) ======================================== Formatted with non-proportional font (Courier) The following tables summarize the respective detection rates of products on different 32-bit platforms (Windows-2000 and Windows-XP respectively, concerning products with results on ALL platforms). Products with identical detection quality for both instantiations of 32-bit engines are marked with "*". Working Hypothesis: ------------------- Scanning engines for 32 bit platforms SHOULD a priori produce equal results (see 6MCMP32.txt). Comparative tables: ------------------- Table Comp.F1v: Detection Quality of Zoo File viruses Table Comp.F1f: Detection Quality of Zoo File infected files Table Comp.F2v: Detection Quality of ITW File viruses Table Comp.F2f: Detection Quality of ITW File infected files Table Comp.F3m: Detection Quality of Zoo File Malware Table Comp.M1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro viruses Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro infected files Table Comp.M2v: Detection Quality of ITW Macro viruses Table Comp.M2f: Detection Quality of ITW Macro infected files Table Comp.M3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Malware Table Comp.S1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Script viruses Table Comp.S1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Script infected files Table Comp.S2v: Detection Quality of ITW Script viruses Table Comp.S2f: Detection Quality of ITW Script infected files Table Comp.S3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Malware Table Comp.F1v: Detection Quality of Zoo File Viruses: ====================================================== ==== Detection Quality ==== W32 Product Windows 2000 Windows XP match Testbed 23209 100.0% 23209 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 21090 90.9% 21090 90.9% * AVA 22214 95.7% 22214 95.7% * AVG 18527 79.8% 18527 79.8% * AVK 23208 100.~% 23208 100.~% * AVP 23201 100.~% 23206 100.~% BDF 19590 84.4% 19590 84.4% * CMD 22891 98.6% 22891 98.6% * DRW 18325 79.0% 18056 77.8% FIR 17503 75.4% 17503 75.4% * FPR 23096 99.5% 23096 99.5% * FSE 23208 100.~% 23208 100.~% * GLA 9437 40.7% 9437 40.7% * IKA 21071 90.8% 21013 90.5% INO 22235 95.8% 22235 95.8% * NAV 23058 99.3% 23058 99.3% * NVC 22041 95.0% 22041 95.0% * PAV 23204 100.~% 23204 100.~% * PER 8330 35.9% 8330 35.9% * PRO 15600 67.2% 15600 67.2% * QHL 13700 59.0% 12987 56.0% RAV 23080 99.4% 23080 99.4% * SCN 23198 100.~% 23198 100.~% * SWP 22782 98.2% 22782 98.2% * VBR 15887 68.5% 15887 68.5% * VSP 3391 14.6% 3391 14.6% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo File infected files: ============================================================= ===== Detection Quality ==== W32 Product Windows 2000 Windows XP match Testbed 166327 100.0% 166327 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 152870 91.9% 152870 91.9% * AVA 161271 97.0% 161271 97.0% * AVG 140021 84.2% 140021 84.2% * AVK 166321 100.~% 166321 100.~% * AVP 166309 100.~% 166313 100.~% BDF 144442 86.8% 144442 86.8% * CMD 164861 99.1% 164861 99.1% * DRW 135529 81.5% 133295 80.1% FIR 91938 55.3% 91938 55.3% * FPR 166069 99.8% 166069 99.8% * FSE 166321 100.~% 166321 100.~% * GLA 59417 35.7% 59417 35.7% * IKA 151335 91.0% 151096 90.8% INO 162888 97.9% 162888 97.9% * NAV 162773 97.9% 162773 97.9% * NVC 160606 96.6% 160605 96.6% PAV 166294 100.~% 166294 100.~% * PER 58628 35.2% 58628 35.2% * PRO 111236 66.9% 111236 66.9% * QHL 58930 35.4% 53559 32.2% RAV 165538 99.5% 165538 99.5% * SCN 166310 100.~% 166310 100.~% * SWP 164343 98.8% 164343 98.8% * VBR 117661 70.7% 117661 70.7% * VSP 22444 13.5% 22444 13.5% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F2v: Detection Quality of ITW File Viruses: ====================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Product Windows 2000 Windows XP match Testbed 107 100.0% 107 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 107 100.0% 107 100.0% * AVA 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * AVG 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * AVK 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * AVP 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * BDF 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * CMD 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * DRW 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * FIR 89 83.2% 89 83.2% * FPR 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * FSE 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * GLA 61 57.0% 61 57.0% * IKA 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * INO 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * NAV 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * NVC 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * PAV 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * PER 71 66.4% 71 66.4% * PRO 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * QHL 103 96.3% 103 96.3% * RAV 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * SCN 107 100.0% 107 100.0% * SWP 106 99.1% 106 99.1% * VBR 103 96.3% 103 96.3% * VSP 3 2.8% 3 2.8% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F2f: Detection Quality of ITW File infected files: ============================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Product Windows 2000 Windows XP match Testbed 638 100.0% 638 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 631 98.9% 631 98.9% * AVA 632 99.1% 632 99.1% * AVG 631 98.9% 631 98.9% * AVK 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * AVP 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * BDF 623 97.6% 623 97.6% * CMD 629 98.6% 629 98.6% * DRW 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * FIR 505 79.2% 505 79.2% * FPR 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * FSE 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * GLA 289 45.3% 289 45.3% * IKA 617 96.7% 617 96.7% * INO 635 99.5% 635 99.5% * NAV 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * NVC 628 98.4% 628 98.4% * PAV 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * PER 438 68.7% 438 68.7% * PRO 618 96.9% 618 96.9% * QHL 611 95.8% 611 95.8% * RAV 637 99.8% 637 99.8% * SCN 638 100.0% 638 100.0% * SWP 635 99.5% 635 99.5% * VBR 552 86.5% 552 86.5% * VSP 104 16.3% 104 16.3% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F3m: Detection Quality of Zoo File Malware: ====================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 28621 100.0% 28621 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 17029 59.5% 17029 59.5% * AVA 18281 63.9% 23055 80.6% AVG 13720 47.9% 13720 47.9% * AVK 28515 99.6% 28515 99.6% * AVP 28112 98.2% 28465 99.5% BDF 19733 68.9% 19733 68.9% * CMD 24976 87.3% 24976 87.3% * DRW 1249 4.4% 1249 4.4% * FIR 10953 38.3% 10953 38.3% * FPR 28308 98.9% 28308 98.9% * FSE 28574 99.8% 28574 99.8% * GLA 10292 36.0% 10292 36.0% * IKA 17409 60.8% 17409 60.8% * INO 22644 79.1% 22644 79.1% * NAV 25579 89.4% 25579 89.4% * NVC 18220 63.7% 18222 63.7% PAV 28442 99.4% 28442 99.4% * PER 1495 5.2% 1495 5.2% * PRO 10233 35.8% 10233 35.8% * QHL 2968 10.4% 2824 9.9% RAV 18316 64.0% 25030 87.5% SCN 28228 98.6% 28228 98.6% * SWP 24558 85.8% 24558 85.8% * VBR 9831 34.3% 9831 34.3% * VSP 6675 23.3% 6675 23.3% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Viruses: ======================================================= ==== Detection Quality ==== W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match Testbed 7796 100.0% 7796 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 7632 97.9% 7632 97.9% * AVA 7630 97.9% 7630 97.9% * AVG 7638 98.0% 7638 98.0% * AVK 7795 100.~% 7795 100.~% * AVP 7795 100.~% 7795 100.~% * BDF 7648 98.1% 7648 98.1% * CMD 7787 99.9% 7787 99.9% * DRW 7750 99.4% 7750 99.4% * FIR 6700 85.9% 6700 85.9% * FPR 7790 99.9% 7790 99.9% * FSE 7795 100.~% 7795 100.~% * GLA 118 1.5% 118 1.5% * IKA 7526 96.5% 5963 76.5% INO 7787 99.9% 7787 99.9% * NAV 7789 99.9% 7789 99.9% * NVC 7737 99.2% 7737 99.2% * PAV 7795 100.~% 7795 100.~% * PER 5441 69.8% 5441 69.8% * PRO 5698 73.1% 5698 73.1% * RAV 7784 99.8% 7784 99.8% * SCN 7795 100.~% 7795 100.~% * SWP 7773 99.7% 7773 99.7% * VBR 7669 98.4% 7671 98.4% VSP 8 0.1% 8 0.1% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro infected files: ============================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 27370 100.0% 27370 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 26757 97.8% 26757 97.8% * AVA 26829 98.0% 26829 98.0% * AVG 26920 98.4% 26920 98.4% * AVK 27367 100.~% 27367 100.~% * AVP 27364 100.~% 27364 100.~% * BDF 26964 98.5% 26964 98.5% * CMD 27348 99.9% 27348 99.9% * DRW 27253 99.6% 27253 99.6% * FIR 23369 85.4% 23369 85.4% * FPR 27352 99.9% 27352 99.9% * FSE 27368 100.~% 27368 100.~% * GLA 375 1.4% 375 1.4% * IKA 26500 96.8% 21784 79.6% INO 27317 99.8% 27317 99.8% * NAV 27340 99.9% 27340 99.9% * NVC 27041 98.8% 27041 98.8% * PAV 27364 100.~% 27364 100.~% * PER 19235 70.3% 19235 70.3% * PRO 19113 69.8% 19113 69.8% * RAV 27328 99.9% 27328 99.9% * SCN 27360 100.~% 27360 100.~% * SWP 27331 99.9% 27331 99.9% * VBR 27078 98.9% 27087 99.0% VSP 9 0.~% 9 0.~% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M2v: Detection Quality of ITW Macro Viruses: ======================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 74 100.0% 74 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * AVA 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * AVG 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * AVK 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * AVP 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * BDF 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * CMD 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * DRW 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * FIR 71 95.9% 71 95.9% * FPR 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * FSE 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * GLA 3 4.1% 3 4.1% * IKA 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * INO 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * NAV 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * NVC 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * PAV 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * PER 64 86.5% 64 86.5% * PRO 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * QHL 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * RAV 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * SCN 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * SWP 74 100.0% 74 100.0% * VBR 73 98.6% 73 98.6% * VSP 1 1.4% 1 1.4% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M2f: Detection Quality of ITW Macro infected files: ============================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 976 100.0% 976 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * AVA 971 99.5% 971 99.5% * AVG 975 99.9% 975 99.9% * AVK 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * AVP 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * BDF 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * CMD 975 99.9% 975 99.9% * DRW 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * FIR 923 94.6% 923 94.6% * FPR 975 99.9% 975 99.9% * FSE 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * GLA 18 1.8% 18 1.8% * IKA 970 99.4% 970 99.4% * INO 975 99.9% 975 99.9% * NAV 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * NVC 965 98.9% 965 98.9% * PAV 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * PER 873 89.4% 873 89.4% * PRO 969 99.3% 969 99.3% * QHL 948 97.1% 948 97.1% * RAV 975 99.9% 975 99.9% * SCN 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * SWP 976 100.0% 976 100.0% * VBR 971 99.5% 971 99.5% * VSP 1 0.1% 1 0.1% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Malware: ======================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 792 100.0% 792 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 696 87.9% 696 87.9% * AVA 724 91.4% 724 91.4% * AVG 644 81.3% 644 81.3% * AVK 792 100.0% 792 100.0% * AVP 791 99.9% 791 99.9% * BDF 750 94.7% 750 94.7% * CMD 792 100.0% 792 100.0% * DRW 783 98.9% 783 98.9% * FIR 599 75.6% 599 75.6% * FPR 792 100.0% 792 100.0% * FSE 792 100.0% 792 100.0% * GLA 15 1.9% 15 1.9% * IKA 725 91.5% 725 91.5% * INO 774 97.7% 774 97.7% * NAV 777 98.1% 777 98.1% * NVC 736 92.9% 736 92.9% * PAV 791 99.9% 791 99.9% * PER 463 58.5% 463 58.5% * PRO 425 53.7% 425 53.7% * QHL 620 78.3% 620 78.3% * RAV 784 99.0% 784 99.0% * SCN 790 99.7% 790 99.7% * SWP 771 97.3% 771 97.3% * VBR 749 94.6% 749 94.6% * VSP 1 0.1% 1 0.1% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Viruses: ======================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 959 100.0% 959 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 839 87.5% 839 87.5% * AVA 851 88.7% 852 88.8% AVG 654 68.2% 654 68.2% * AVK 957 99.8% 957 99.8% * AVP 956 99.7% 956 99.7% * BDF 904 94.3% 904 94.3% * CMD 945 98.5% 945 98.5% * DRW 915 95.4% 915 95.4% * FIR 728 75.9% 728 75.9% * FPR 952 99.3% 952 99.3% * FSE 959 100.0% 959 100.0% * GLA 475 49.5% 475 49.5% * IKA 879 91.7% 879 91.7% * INO 935 97.5% 935 97.5% * NAV 947 98.7% 947 98.7% * NVC 828 86.3% 828 86.3% * PAV 956 99.7% 956 99.7% * PER 220 22.9% 220 22.9% * PRO 675 70.4% 675 70.4% * QHL 279 29.1% 279 29.1% * RAV 956 99.7% 956 99.7% * SCN 959 100.0% 959 100.0% * SWP 928 96.8% 928 96.8% * VBR 445 46.4% 445 46.4% * VSP 801 83.5% 801 83.5% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Script infected files: =============================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 2222 100.0% 2222 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 1796 80.8% 1796 80.8% * AVA 1916 86.2% 1923 86.5% AVG 1566 70.5% 1566 70.5% * AVK 2218 99.8% 2218 99.8% * AVP 2216 99.7% 2216 99.7% * BDF 2008 90.4% 2008 90.4% * CMD 2136 96.1% 2136 96.1% * DRW 2080 93.6% 2080 93.6% * FIR 1434 64.5% 1434 64.5% * FPR 2191 98.6% 2191 98.6% * FSE 2219 99.9% 2219 99.9% * GLA 1096 49.3% 1096 49.3% * IKA 1955 88.0% 1955 88.0% * INO 2147 96.6% 2147 96.6% * NAV 2185 98.3% 2185 98.3% * NVC 1794 80.7% 1794 80.7% * PAV 2216 99.7% 2216 99.7% * PER 632 28.4% 632 28.4% * PRO 1464 65.9% 1464 65.9% * QHL 832 37.4% 832 37.4% * RAV 2192 98.6% 2192 98.6% * SCN 2218 99.8% 2218 99.8% * SWP 2099 94.5% 2099 94.5% * VBR 1127 50.7% 1127 50.7% * VSP 1614 72.6% 1614 72.6% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S2v: Detection Quality of ITW Script Viruses: ======================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 22 100.0% 22 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * AVA 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * AVG 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * AVK 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * AVP 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * BDF 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * CMD 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * DRW 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * FIR 21 95.5% 21 95.5% * FPR 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * FSE 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * GLA 12 54.5% 12 54.5% * IKA 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * INO 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * NAV 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * NVC 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * PAV 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * PER 15 68.2% 15 68.2% * PRO 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * QHL 21 95.5% 21 95.5% * RAV 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * SCN 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * SWP 22 100.0% 22 100.0% * VBR 16 72.7% 16 72.7% * VSP 20 90.9% 20 90.9% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S2f: Detection Quality of ITW Script infected files: ============================================================ === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 178 100.0% 178 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 154 86.5% 154 86.5% * AVA 174 97.8% 174 97.8% * AVG 169 94.9% 169 94.9% * AVK 178 100.0% 178 100.0% * AVP 178 100.0% 178 100.0% * BDF 172 96.6% 172 96.6% * CMD 174 97.8% 174 97.8% * DRW 174 97.8% 174 97.8% * FIR 137 77.0% 137 77.0% * FPR 177 99.4% 177 99.4% * FSE 178 100.0% 178 100.0% * GLA 113 63.5% 113 63.5% * IKA 176 98.9% 176 98.9% * INO 177 99.4% 177 99.4% * NAV 178 100.0% 178 100.0% * NVC 168 94.4% 168 94.4% * PAV 178 100.0% 178 100.0% * PER 104 58.4% 104 58.4% * PRO 151 84.8% 151 84.8% * QHL 154 86.5% 154 86.5% * RAV 177 99.4% 177 99.4% * SCN 178 100.0% 178 100.0% * SWP 168 94.4% 168 94.4% * VBR 129 72.5% 129 72.5% * VSP 145 81.5% 145 81.5% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Malware: ======================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Windows 2000 Windows XP match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 1103 100.0% 1103 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- ANT 394 35.7% 394 35.7% * AVA 782 70.9% 782 70.9% * AVG 183 16.6% 183 16.6% * AVK 1085 98.4% 1085 98.4% * AVP 1075 97.5% 1075 97.5% * BDF 441 40.0% 441 40.0% * CMD 577 52.3% 577 52.3% * DRW 634 57.5% 634 57.5% * FIR 168 15.2% 168 15.2% * FPR 868 78.7% 868 78.7% * FSE 1086 98.5% 1086 98.5% * GLA 128 11.6% 128 11.6% * IKA 393 35.6% 393 35.6% * INO 688 62.4% 688 62.4% * NAV 967 87.7% 967 87.7% * NVC 212 19.2% 212 19.2% * PAV 1074 97.4% 1074 97.4% * PER 18 1.6% 18 1.6% * PRO 235 21.3% 235 21.3% * QHL 141 12.8% 141 12.8% * RAV 922 83.6% 922 83.6% * SCN 1067 96.7% 1067 96.7% * SWP 648 58.7% 648 58.7% * VBR 106 9.6% 106 9.6% * VSP 197 17.9% 197 17.9% * -----------------------------------------------