======================================== aVTC Test "2002-12" (File 6MCMP32.TXT): ---------------------------------------- Comparison of Detection Quality of 32-Bit Scanning Engines: (Win-98 / Win-2000) ======================================== Formatted with non-proportional font (Courier) The following tables summarize the respective detection rates of products on different 32-bit platforms (Windows 98 and Windows-2000 respectively, concerning products with results on ALL platforms). Products with identical detection quality for both instantiations of 32-bit engines are marked with "*". Comparative tables: ------------------- Table Comp.F1v: Detection Quality of Zoo File viruses Table Comp.F1f: Detection Quality of Zoo File infected files Table Comp.F2v: Detection Quality of ITW File viruses Table Comp.F2f: Detection Quality of ITW File infected files Table Comp.F3m: Detection Quality of Zoo File Malware Table Comp.M1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro viruses Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro infected files Table Comp.M2v: Detection Quality of ITW Macro viruses Table Comp.M2f: Detection Quality of ITW Macro infected files Table Comp.M3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Malware Table Comp.S1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Script viruses Table Comp.S1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Script infected files Table Comp.S2v: Detection Quality of ITW Script viruses Table Comp.S2f: Detection Quality of ITW Script infected files Table Comp.S3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Malware Table Comp.F1v: Detection Quality of Zoo File Viruses: ====================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 21790 100.0% 21790 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 20960 96.2% 20962 96.2% AVG 17555 80.6% 17556 80.6% AVK 21777 99.9% 21777 99.9% * AVP 21783 100.~% 21783 100.~% * BDF 18054 82.9% 18054 82.9% * CMD 21458 98.5% 21458 98.5% * DRW 21414 98.3% 21414 98.3% * FPR 21526 98.8% 21526 98.8% * FPW 21524 98.8% 21524 98.8% * FSE 21784 100.~% 21780 100.~% INO 21514 98.7% 21514 98.7% * MR2 2068 9.5% 274 1.3% NAV 21428 98.3% 2532 11.6% NVC 21314 97.8% 21313 97.8% PRO 15344 70.4% 15144 69.5% RAV 20626 94.7% 21065 96.7% SCN 21736 99.8% 21736 99.8% * VSP 3043 14.0% 1059 4.9% ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo File infected files: ============================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 158747 100.0% 158747 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 152447 96.0% 152468 96.0% AVG 133992 84.4% 133993 84.4% AVK 158679 100.~% 158679 100.~% * AVP 158701 100.~% 158701 100.~% * BDF 135716 85.5% 135716 85.5% * CMD 157448 99.2% 157448 99.2% * DRW 156764 98.8% 156767 98.8% FPR 157777 99.4% 157777 99.4% * FPW 157725 99.4% 157725 99.4% * FSE 158702 100.~% 158690 100.~% INO 157117 99.0% 157117 99.0% * MR2 14952 9.4% 2514 1.6% NAV 152965 96.4% 19747 12.4% NVC 155577 98.0% 155567 98.0% PRO 108070 68.1% 106412 67.0% RAV 149695 94.3% 153343 96.6% SCN 158425 99.8% 158425 99.8% * VSP 21126 13.3% 8601 5.4% ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F2v: Detection Quality of ITW File Viruses: ====================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 50 100.0% 50 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * AVG 49 98.0% 49 98.0% * AVK 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * AVP 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * BDF 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * CMD 49 98.0% 49 98.0% * DRW 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * FPR 48 96.0% 49 98.0% FPW 49 98.0% 49 98.0% * FSE 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * INO 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * MR2 12 24.0% 12 24.0% * NAV 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * NVC 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * PRO 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * RAV 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * SCN 50 100.0% 50 100.0% * VSP 5 10.0% 5 10.0% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F2f: Detection Quality of ITW File infected files: ============================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 443 100.0% 443 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 434 98.2% 434 98.2% * AVG 435 98.4% 435 98.4% * AVK 442 100.0% 442 100.0% * AVP 442 100.0% 442 100.0% * BDF 428 96.8% 428 96.8% * CMD 433 98.0% 433 98.0% * DRW 442 100.0% 442 100.0% * FPR 430 97.3% 433 98.0% FPW 433 98.0% 433 98.0% * FSE 442 100.0% 442 100.0% * INO 441 99.8% 441 99.8% * MR2 169 38.2% 169 38.2% * NAV 442 100.0% 442 100.0% * NVC 430 97.3% 430 97.3% * PRO 404 91.4% 404 91.4% * RAV 438 99.1% 438 99.1% * SCN 442 100.0% 442 100.0% * VSP 120 27.1% 120 27.1% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F3m: Detection Quality of Zoo File Malware: ====================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 18278 100.0% 18278 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 13654 74.7% 13654 74.7% * AVG 8242 45.1% 8242 45.1% * AVK 18076 98.9% 18076 98.9% * AVP 18098 99.0% 18098 99.0% * BDF 9903 54.2% 9903 54.2% * CMD 16184 88.5% 16184 88.5% * DRW 13424 73.4% 13424 73.4% * FPR 16290 89.1% 16290 89.1% * FPW 16287 89.1% 16287 89.1% * FSE 18169 99.4% 18139 99.2% INO 14062 76.9% 14132 77.3% MR2 1394 7.6% 3791 20.7% NAV 13275 72.6% 13255 72.5% NVC 14440 79.0% 14439 79.0% PRO 5200 28.4% 5200 28.4% * RAV 15026 82.2% 15026 82.2% * SCN 17457 95.5% 17457 95.5% * VSP 4852 26.5% 4852 26.5% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Viruses: ======================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 7306 100.0 7306 100.0 ----------------------------------------------- AVA 7147 97.8% 7147 97.8% * AVG 7167 98.1% 7167 98.1% * AVK 7304 100.~% 7304 100.~% * AVP 7304 100.~% 7304 100.~% * BDF 7231 99.0% 7231 99.0% * CMD 7302 99.9% 7302 99.9% * DRW 7263 99.4% 7263 99.4% * FPR 7303 100.~% 7303 100.~% * FPW 7303 100.~% 7303 100.~% * FSE 7305 100.~% 7305 100.~% * INO 7298 99.9% 7298 99.9% * MR2 761 10.4% 2769 37.9% NAV 7280 99.6% 7290 99.8% NVC 7295 99.8% 7295 99.8% * PRO 5315 72.7% 5315 72.7% * RAV 7299 99.9% 7299 99.9% * SCN 7306 100.0% 7306 100.0% * VSP 2 0.~% 2 0.~% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro infected files: ============================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 25231 100.0% 25231 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 24703 97.9% 24703 97.9% * AVG 24772 98.2% 24772 98.2% * AVK 25193 99.8% 25193 99.8% * AVP 25193 99.8% 25193 99.8% * BDF 24942 98.9% 24942 98.9% * CMD 25199 99.9% 25199 99.9% * DRW 25110 99.5% 25110 99.5% * FPR 25200 99.9% 25200 99.9% * FPW 25200 99.9% 25200 99.9% * FSE 25222 100.~% 25222 100.~% * INO 25204 99.9% 25204 99.9% * MR2 2254 8.9% 8117 32.2% NAV 25119 99.6% 25152 99.7% NVC 25161 99.7% 25161 99.7% * PRO 17535 69.5% 17535 69.5% * RAV 25211 99.9% 25211 99.9% * SCN 25227 100.~% 25227 100.~% * VSP 2 0.~% 2 0.~% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M2v: Detection Quality of ITW Macro Viruses: ======================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 124 100.0 124 100.0 ----------------------------------------------- AVA 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * AVG 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * AVK 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * AVP 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * BDF 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * CMD 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * DRW 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * FPR 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * FPW 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * FSE 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * INO 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * MR2 11 8.9% 11 8.9% * NAV 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * NVC 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * PRO 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * RAV 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * SCN 124 100.0% 124 100.0% * VSP 0 0.0% 0 0.0% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M2f: Detection Quality of ITW Macro infected files: ============================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 1332 99.6% 1332 99.6% * AVG 1336 99.9% 1336 99.9% * AVK 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * AVP 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * BDF 1336 99.9% 1336 99.9% * CMD 1336 99.9% 1336 99.9% * DRW 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * FPR 1336 99.9% 1336 99.9% * FPW 1336 99.9% 1336 99.9% * FSE 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * INO 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * MR2 374 28.0% 374 28.0% * NAV 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * NVC 1335 99.9% 1335 99.9% * PRO 1327 99.3% 1327 99.3% * RAV 1334 99.8% 1334 99.8% * SCN 1337 100.0% 1337 100.0% * VSP 0 0.0% 0 0.0% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Malware: ======================================================= === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 747 100.0% 747 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 646 86.5% 646 86.5% * AVG 621 83.1% 621 83.1% * AVK 745 99.7% 745 99.7% * AVP 745 99.7% 745 99.7% * BDF 679 90.9% 679 90.9% * CMD 735 98.4% 735 98.4% * DRW 683 91.4% 683 91.4% * FPR 735 98.4% 735 98.4% * FPW 735 98.4% 735 98.4% * FSE 745 99.7% 745 99.7% * INO 709 94.9% 709 94.9% * MR2 205 27.4% 205 27.4% * NAV 679 90.9% 681 91.2% NVC 711 95.2% 710 95.0% PRO 391 52.3% 391 52.3% * RAV 730 97.7% 729 97.6% SCN 745 99.7% 745 99.7% * VSP 1 0.1% 1 0.1% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Viruses: ======================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 823 100.0% 823 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 259 31.5% 259 31.5% * AVG 526 63.9% 526 63.9% * AVK 815 99.0% 815 99.0% * AVP 814 98.9% 814 98.9% * BDF 594 72.2% 596 72.4% CMD 733 89.1% 733 89.1% * DRW 779 94.7% 779 94.7% * FPR 730 88.7% 730 88.7% * FPW 730 88.7% 730 88.7% * FSE 819 99.5% 819 99.5% * INO 779 94.7% 779 94.7% * MR2 667 81.0% 667 81.0% * NAV 797 96.8% 798 97.0% NVC 721 87.6% 721 87.6% * PRO 492 59.8% 492 59.8% * RAV 791 96.1% 791 96.1% * SCN 820 99.6% 820 99.6% * VSP 668 81.2% 668 81.2% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Script infected files: =============================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 1574 100.0% 1574 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 565 35.9% 565 35.9% * AVG 1014 64.4% 1014 64.4% * AVK 1563 99.3% 1563 99.3% * AVP 1562 99.2% 1562 99.2% * BDF 1068 67.9% 1074 68.2% CMD 1342 85.3% 1342 85.3% * DRW 1436 91.2% 1436 91.2% * FPR 1335 84.8% 1335 84.8% * FPW 1333 84.7% 1333 84.7% * FSE 1566 99.5% 1568 99.6% INO 1457 92.6% 1457 92.6% * MR2 1146 72.8% 1146 72.8% * NAV 1490 94.7% 1497 95.1% NVC 1270 80.7% 1270 80.7% * PRO 873 55.5% 873 55.5% * RAV 1496 95.0% 1496 95.0% * SCN 1570 99.7% 1570 99.7% * VSP 1148 72.9% 1148 72.9% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S2v: Detection Quality of ITW Script Viruses: ======================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 20 100.0% 20 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * AVG 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * AVK 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * AVP 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * BDF 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * CMD 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * DRW 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * FPR 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * FPW 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * FSE 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * INO 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * MR2 18 90.0% 18 90.0% * NAV 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * NVC 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * PRO 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * RAV 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * SCN 20 100.0% 20 100.0% * VSP 18 90.0% 18 90.0% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S2f: Detection Quality of ITW Script infected files: ============================================================ === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 122 100.0% 122 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 114 93.4% 114 93.4% * AVG 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * AVK 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * AVP 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * BDF 119 97.5% 119 97.5% * CMD 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * DRW 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * FPR 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * FPW 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * FSE 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * INO 121 99.2% 121 99.2% * MR2 99 81.1% 99 81.1% * NAV 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * NVC 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * PRO 118 96.7% 118 96.7% * RAV 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * SCN 122 100.0% 122 100.0% * VSP 99 81.1% 99 81.1% * ----------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Malware: ======================================================== === Detection Quality === W32 Scanner Win-2k % Win-98 % match ----------------------------------------------- Testbed 202 100.0% 202 100.0% ----------------------------------------------- AVA 2 1.0% 2 1.0% * AVG 15 7.4% 15 7.4% * AVK 189 93.6% 189 93.6% * AVP 189 93.6% 189 93.6% * BDF 40 19.8% 43 21.3% CMD 36 17.8% 36 17.8% * DRW 120 59.4% 120 59.4% * FPR 36 17.8% 36 17.8% * FPW 36 17.8% 36 17.8% * FSE 192 95.0% 192 95.0% * INO 114 56.4% 114 56.4% * MR2 33 16.3% 33 16.3% * NAV 160 79.2% 163 80.7% NVC 32 15.8% 32 15.8% * PRO 37 18.3% 37 18.3% * RAV 145 71.8% 145 71.8% * SCN 188 93.1% 188 93.1% * VSP 33 16.3% 33 16.3% * -----------------------------------------------